Skip to main content
← All news & articles
Electronic Signatures

SES vs AES vs QES: Which Signature Do You Need?

András Somkuti ·

Electronic signing has become sufficiently ordinary that we rarely stop to consider what the word “signature” actually describes. A name typed below an email, a signature drawn on a touchscreen and a cryptographically created qualified electronic signature may all belong to the same broad digital category, yet the confidence they offer about identity, document integrity and the circumstances of signing can be radically different.

For organisations moving significant parts of their contracting and approval processes online, those differences are more than technical vocabulary. The more useful question is not whether a document has been electronically signed, but what can reasonably be established about that signature if somebody later disputes it.

European regulation provides a useful framework for approaching that question. Under eIDAS, electronic signatures exist at different levels of assurance, although the frequently used expression “simple electronic signature”, or SES, is an industry shorthand rather than a formally defined eIDAS category. Advanced electronic signatures and qualified electronic signatures, by contrast, are associated with specific regulatory requirements.

The broad territory of simple electronic signatures

At the simpler end of the spectrum sit methods such as typing a name into an online form, pasting a scanned handwritten signature into a document or confirming acceptance through a digital interface. Depending on the surrounding process, these actions can constitute an electronic signature, and their relative simplicity should not be confused with an absence of legal relevance.

eIDAS expressly states that an electronic signature cannot be denied legal effect or admissibility as evidence solely because it is electronic or because it does not satisfy the requirements of a qualified electronic signature.

What changes as assurance increases is the quality of the evidence surrounding the action.

If a disagreement develops six months later, can the organisation establish who controlled the account used for signing? Was the signer authenticated? Can the exact version of the document be reconstructed? Could somebody have copied the visible signature from another file? Does the process preserve evidence of intention?

In a low-risk transaction, the answers may be perfectly adequate even when the signing mechanism itself is relatively simple. A process does not become better merely by introducing the highest possible assurance level.

Advanced signatures move the emphasis towards evidence

An advanced electronic signature, or AES, has a considerably more defined relationship with both the signer and the signed data. Under eIDAS, it must be uniquely linked to the signatory, capable of identifying that person, created using signature-creation data under the signatory’s control with a high level of confidence, and connected to the signed information so that later changes can be detected.

The distinction is subtle but important. A signature is no longer primarily a visual representation of agreement; it becomes part of an evidentiary structure.

Qualified signatures introduce regulated trust

A qualified electronic signature, or QES, builds on the advanced-signature model while adding a qualified certificate and a qualified signature-creation environment within the European trust-services framework.

The legal distinction is unusually clear: eIDAS gives a qualified electronic signature the equivalent legal effect of a handwritten signature.

Behind that status sits an infrastructure involving qualified trust service providers, regulated certificate issuance, verified identity, protected signature-creation data and mechanisms that enable the signature to be validated later. Qualification therefore belongs to the whole trust framework surrounding the transaction, not merely to an icon or visual mark added to a PDF.

It is also why the existence of a digital certificate alone does not establish that a signature is qualified. European Trusted Lists play a central role in identifying which providers and services have qualified status, and qualification is attached to the specific trust service listed there.

The right signature is a risk decision

The temptation in digitalisation projects is to turn signature selection into an IT procurement question: which method is fastest, cheapest or easiest to integrate? But a more mature discussion starts elsewhere.

A routine internal acknowledgement and a multimillion-euro agreement do not create the same evidentiary exposure. Neither do an employee policy acceptance, a regulated declaration, a procurement approval and a transaction that could be litigated years later.

As the consequence of a disputed action increases, organisations generally need stronger answers to questions around identity, intention, integrity and time. There may also be statutory or contractual form requirements that determine which level of signature is appropriate.

Seen from that perspective, SES, AES and QES are not simply three versions of the same feature arranged from basic to premium. They represent different ways of distributing trust and evidentiary risk across a digital transaction.

Get your qualified electronic signature in about 3 minutes from sign-up. Identify yourself by video on any device with a camera, or faster with the Netlock mobile app and a chip identity card. Every signature gets a qualified time stamp. Sign up for free and start with 15 free signatures.

How Netlock’s QES works

Related articles

Tell Us What You Need to Prove

We'll show you the fastest way to start, from one workflow to an organisation-wide proof layer.

Sign up for free