Skip to main content

Identity Is Not Authority: Proving Who Someone Is Is Only Half the Problem

András Somkuti ·

Digital identity projects often approach trust as though establishing the human being behind an action completes the problem. In many enterprise transactions, it merely establishes the actor. The organisation must still understand the capacity in which that actor is operating.

And the problem is that even though a person is real and has been identified, they can still perform an unauthorised action. The distinction becomes clearer when we separate two questions that are frequently bundled together:

“Who are you?” concerns identity.

“What may you do here?” concerns authority.

A procurement manager may have authority to execute supplier agreements below a certain value while requiring board approval above that threshold. A managing director may represent one subsidiary but not another. An employee may temporarily receive delegated approval rights while a colleague is absent. Two executives may be required to act jointly for particular transactions.

Every individual involved can be exactly who they claim to be, yet the transaction can still fall outside the authority granted to them. Identity assurance therefore reduces impersonation risk without automatically resolving governance risk.

Corporate authority is unusually dynamic

Human identity tends to be relatively stable. Corporate authority changes continually. Just a few examples: people are promoted, moved between functions or removed from roles, powers of attorney are issued and withdrawn, approval limits change, legal entities are reorganised, etc. This dynamism makes authority difficult to encode in a static credential or one-time verification.

A system that verified a senior manager six months ago may still recognise that individual perfectly today, while its assumption about the person’s organisational rights has become obsolete. That temporal element becomes particularly important when verified identities are reused across multiple transactions. Reusability is valuable only when the attributes relied upon remain appropriate for the decision being made.

Representation sits between identity and signature

Enterprise signing makes the issue especially visible. A signature can establish that a particular person approved a particular document. It cannot automatically establish the corporate governance rules under which that approval became sufficient.

The surrounding process may need to understand whether the signer represents the legal entity, whether the mandate covers the transaction, whether a monetary threshold has been exceeded, whether another approval is required or whether a delegated authority was still active at the moment of signing.

In other words, the evidence associated with a corporate act often has at least three layers: the person, the authority and the action. Treating only the final signature as the trust event compresses those layers into a single moment and risks losing the reasoning that made the action legitimate.

Delegation deserves its own audit history

Delegated authority is a useful example precisely because it appears so mundane. For example, a CFO goes on holiday and assigns certain approval rights to a deputy for two weeks. Operationally, nothing about this arrangement is unusual. From an evidentiary perspective, however, the later transaction may depend on being able to establish who granted the delegation, its exact scope, when it became effective, when it expired and whether any conditions were attached. The more complex the organisation, the more frequently such authority is conditional rather than absolute.

Identity is moving towards context

The next stage of digital identity is likely to become increasingly attribute-driven. The emerging European Digital Identity framework already places significant emphasis on electronic attestations of attributes alongside identification itself, creating mechanisms through which verified information can be held and presented within the broader wallet ecosystem.

For enterprises, the interesting possibility lies in extending the idea of trusted attributes towards organisational context. A meaningful digital representation of an actor may eventually need to express not merely a name and identity but a current relationship with an organisation, a role, a mandate, a limit or another relevant entitlement.

At that point, digital trust becomes less about proving that a person exists and more about establishing the legitimacy of a particular action in a particular context.

Tell Us What You Need to Prove

We’ll show you the fastest way to start, from one workflow to an organisation-wide proof layer.

Sign up for free